I was reading up on what is happening in Artificial Intelligence
and Machine Learning and listened to a few lectures/interviews. It looks
like next few years will see a significant advance in these fields and it could
bring disruption to lot of industries.
Here is a pop science / layman version of what
I understood.
TL;DR version:-
- Research in something called Deep
Learning has reached the tipping point where it is industrial strength in
performance and it could be used for real world applications.
- 3 things that are pushing it – cheap
parallel computing (GPUs), big data (collected through search, images,
posts etc), better algorithms (deep learning)
- Focus in not on the kind of AI seen in
the likes of Terminator and by all accounts we are too far from it. While
robotics is progressing, that is also not where AI is getting applied (to
set our mental image right). But it is on developing intelligent machines
doing specific functions (speech recognition, natural language processing,
image recognition etc).
- In past 3-4 years, AI has started moving from academia
into big corporates. Leading researchers and professors from top
universities are moving into companies like Google, Facebook. There is an
AI arms race going on between Google, Facebook, Microsoft, IBM, Baidu,
Amazon. It is about who will create the killer app using AI/ML first.
- What is really happening is not purely AI
or ML – someone coined the term AI + ML = MI (Machine Intelligence).
Making machines intelligent enough to do specific functions better, at
scale not possible by humans.
- X.AI – Next round of innovation could be
to take anything (X) and add AI to it to make it better – like medical
image processing, fraud detection, recommendation systems.
- Last year, some of the very intelligent
people like Stephen Hawking, Elon Musk and Bill Gates made statements that
AI could be an existential threat and it is not far off. Do they know
something that the generic public don’t?
Longer version:-
AI coming out hibernation
AI was sputtering along since 1960s, like the
analyst asked. Creating logical models, reverse engineering the brain or basing
AI research on neuroscience was not making significant progress and with not
much commercial use, funding also was a problem. These periods of lull in AI
research where it went to hibernate is referred to as “AI winters”. But few
researchers like Geoffrey Hinton in University of Montreal, Yoshua Bengio of
University of Toronto, Yann LeCun of NYU were still continuing their struggle.
Yann LeCun created a cheque reading system while he was with Bell Labs and
AT&T.
Eventually they created something called Deep
Learning – it is layers of neural network which starts off with basic input
(like images, text – at pixels and letters), understands features, classifies
and comes up with an output. Something called backpropagation can compare the
output and any errors can be fed back through the neural net to adjust the
weights to improve the accuracy. Once they feed in millions of data to train
the neural network, system learns to do this automatically. There is supervised
learning where a training data set and valid outputs are used at first.
Unsupervised learning is where data without labels can also be classified,
features generated by the machine and learn by itself. LeCun describes this
process as a black box with 500 million knobs – you show it a picture of a car
and at the end of it, it says it is a truck – you turn some of the knobs,
correcting the parameters and weights and it learns that this is a car. Repeat
this few million times to let the system learn.
Another significant event that helped this along
seems to be the brainwave to use Graphic Process Units (GPUs) that were
specifically developed for rendering high resolution graphics for video games
getting adopted for AI. GPUs can do complex computations using multi
dimensional vectors faster and it is optimized for throughput, not latency like
the CPUs. Multiple GPUs that can be process such huge tasks of crunching
millions of data in a parallel processing environment is giving huge
performance boost – it seems turning Deep Learning experiments that used to
take weeks down to days or hours.
Google came out with a result where the
unsupervised system learned from millions of Youtube videos and learned to
recognize image of a cat on its own. Or another where the system learned to
play games on its own and beat human performance.
By now it is ready for showtime and likes of
Google/Facebook stand to gain from advances in voice, image, text processing.
Advantage of Google and Facebook is huge amount of real data that they get from
searches, content and social connections. As per Peter Norvig, modern AI is
about “data, data, data,” and Google has more data than anyone else. That and
unlimited processing power makes it ideal environment for research. All leading
AI researchers are in these companies now – Hinton in Google, LeCun in
Facebook. Andrew Ng of Stanford and Google joined Baidu Research. Peter Norvig
who wrote AI textbook is in Google, same as Ray Kurzweil who is a leading AI
figure who says we will have human level AI in next 15 years.
We have started using some versions of it
though. Google Now in my android phone read my email the other day and gave a
reminder about a movie based on the ticket receipt I had in my email. When I
was in Bangalore, it gave a reminder at 4 pm that it was time for me to start
to airport for a 7:30 flight (I had the tickets in my email) – considering the
traffic. Facebook is showing me another person in my flat as friend
recommendation – it might have been based on my location. Apple’s Siri,
Microsoft’s Cortana, IBM’s Watson are others. It seems Watson is offered as a
service for medical diagnosis and research. Skype announced real time
translation service recently. Baidu seems to be going one step further about
multi lingual translation.
Microsoft is a surprise leader too. Azure ML
seems to have big plans – of eventually even giving Deep Learning as a service
with fully trained neural nets for image, text and voice. Amazon announced
Machine Learning service as well. Big advantage they have is cloud environments
that can be provisioned for on demand analysis. That is perfect combination –
processing power and algorithms as a service.
Applicability of such MI super specialty could
be in things like fraud detection, demand forecasting, ad targeting,
recommendation, spam filtering, healthcare. Personalized medicine, genome
sequencing, driverless cars – those are what is coming.
AI scare and criticism
Last year Stephen Hawking said that "The
development of full artificial intelligence could spell the end of the human
race. Once humans develop artificial intelligence it will take off on its own
and redesign itself at an ever-increasing rate". Incidentally he was using
improved version of his speech software while talking to BBC, which kind of
guesses the words he would use next, learning from his past talks. Another was
Elon Musk, of Tesla Motors and SpaceX (potential real life Iron Man) who said
“With artificial intelligence we are summoning the demon”. He called it
"our greatest existential threat". Irony again is, he was an investor
in Deep Mind, an AI company that Google acquired for 400 million.
Ray Kurzweil believes computers will reach
Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) by 2029 and that by 2045, we’ll have not
only Artificial Super Intelligence (ASI), but a full-blown new world—a time he
calls the singularity. And last year a computer AI claims to have passed 65
year old Turing Test (experiment based on Alan Turing’s “Can Machines Think?”)
for the first time..
But those including LeCun believes we are far
off – he said it is like driving in a highway under heavy fog and we don’t know
when we will hit the next major brick wall which the research cannot surmount
for another long period of time. An article in New Yorker says we haven’t
reached far enough with the research – “Hinton has built a better ladder; but a
better ladder doesn’t necessarily get you to the moon.” Or this quote captures
the state better – “The current "AI scare" going on feels a bit like
kids playing with Legos and worrying about accidentally creating a nuclear
bomb.”
There are more critics of this probabilistic,
brute force, data driven approach to AI. Douglas Hofstadter who is author of
“Godel, Escher and Bach” said “I don’t want to be involved in passing off some
fancy program’s behavior for intelligence when I know that it has nothing to do
with intelligence.” As per Noam Chomsky, “field’s heavy use of statistical
techniques to pick regularities in masses of data is unlikely to yield the
explanatory insight that science ought to offer. the "new AI" —
focused on using statistical learning techniques to better mine and predict
data — is unlikely to yield general principles about the nature of intelligent
beings or about cognition.”
AI scare is also related to loss of jobs. But
job loss is connected to various other things, not just AI/ML. Industrial
robotics is making significant progress. Read somewhere that “Oxford University
researchers have estimated that 47 percent of U.S. jobs could be automated
within the next two decades.” China is aggressively moving towards it –
manufacturing, assembly line jobs getting automated. Repetitive jobs getting
automated will anyway affect every industry, by AI or not. Drones is other –
this week there was news about a patent filing by Amazon on drones tracking
customer location for accurate delivery. These could be further enhanced and
accelerated by use of data and AI/ML.
Summary – AI as extra IQ
A good summary is this quote from a Wired
article “The Three Breakthroughs That Have Finally Unleashed AI on the World” – http://www.wired.com/2014/10/future-of-artificial-intelligence/
“A picture of our AI future is coming into view, and it is not
the HAL 9000—a discrete machine animated by a charismatic (yet potentially
homicidal) humanlike consciousness—or a Singularitan rapture of
superintelligence. The AI on the horizon looks more like Amazon Web
Services—cheap, reliable, industrial-grade digital smartness running behind
everything, and almost invisible except when it blinks off. This common utility
will serve you as much IQ as you want but no more than you need. Like all
utilities, AI will be supremely boring, even as it transforms the Internet, the
global economy, and civilization. It will enliven inert objects, much as
electricity did more than a century ago. Everything that we formerly
electrified we will now cognitize. This new utilitarian AI will also augment us
individually as people (deepening our memory, speeding our recognition) and
collectively as a species. There is almost nothing we can think of that cannot
be made new, different, or interesting by infusing it with some extra IQ. In
fact, the business plans of the next 10,000 startups are easy to forecast:Take
X and add AI. This is a big deal, and now it’s here.”
——————-
Good reads:-
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AbjVdBKfkO0 –
interview with Yann Lecun
- http://www.shivonzilis.com/machineintelligence –
The Current State of Machine Intelligence
- http://chronicle.com/article/The-Believers/190147/ –
The Believers – The hidden story behind the code that runs our lives.
Interview with Geoffrey Hinton
- http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2013/11/the-man-who-would-teach-machines-to-think/309529/ –
The Man Who Would Teach Machines to Think, on Douglas
Hofstatder how lonely he might feel now – with the world
celebrating AI which according to him is crunching data faster
- https://medium.com/backchannel/how-google-search-dealt-with-mobile-33bc09852dc9 –
Stephen Levy’s 4 part series about Google, includes interview with Deep
Mind’s founder
- http://spectrum.ieee.org/automaton/robotics/artificial-intelligence/facebook-ai-director-yann-lecun-on-deep-learning –
interview with Yann LeCun
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=quWFjS3Ci7A, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UtBa9yVZBJM – Amazon warehouse robots